DIY SEO vs Hiring an SEO Expert

DIY SEO vs Hiring an SEO Expert

When diving into the world of online marketing, you’re faced with a pivotal decision: should you tackle search engine optimisation (SEO) on your own or engage the services of a professional? In this article, we’ll unravel the pros and cons of DIY SEO against hiring an SEO expert, specifically from our reputable brand, Searchical.

The Allure of DIY SEO

  1. Cost-Effective (Initially)

When you’re starting out, every penny counts. Opting for DIY SEO means you’re not spending on professional fees.

  1. Personal Touch

Directly managing your SEO gives you a say in how your brand is portrayed.

  1. Learning Opportunity

It’s an excellent chance to learn a new skill.

Why DIY SEO Might Not Be Your Cup of Tea

  1. It’s Time-Consuming

SEO isn’t just about embedding keywords. It encompasses site audits, link building, content creation, and more. This could take away time from your core business activities.

  1. The Learning Curve

SEO is ever-evolving. Google’s algorithms change. New trends emerge. Keeping up can be a daunting task.

  1. Risks of Missteps

A wrong move could result in your website being penalised. Remember, recovering from a penalty is often harder than getting it right the first time.

Benefits of Hiring an SEO Expert

  1. Experience Counts

A professional from Searchical would have dealt with diverse industries and challenges. This experience can be invaluable.

  1. Tools and Resources

Experts often have access to premium tools and resources. For instance, an overview of digital tools endorsed by the Australian Government shows the depth of resources available.

  1. Results-Oriented Approach

Their main aim is to ensure your website ranks high. This often translates into a better return on investment (ROI).

  1. Keeps Up with Trends

SEO experts, Searchical, stay updated with the latest in the SEO world, ensuring your business isn’t left behind.

The Price of Professionalism

  1. Initial Costs

Hiring an expert can be an investment. However, consider it a long-term game with potential high returns.

  1. Letting Go

Entrusting your brand’s online image to another can be tough. But remember, it’s in the hands of experts who want the best for your business.

A Deeper Dive into DIY SEO

The realm of DIY SEO is vast and can be likened to stepping into a lush forest with a myriad of paths to explore. For many, it presents an opportunity to gain a richer understanding of their website’s digital fabric.

Holistic Control Over Your Digital Presence

By handling SEO in-house, you maintain a complete grasp over your digital narrative. Every keyword chosen, every meta tag written, and every backlink earned is under your purview. This can bring a sense of satisfaction, knowing you’re sculpting your brand’s online identity firsthand.

Flexibility to Iterate and Experiment

The digital landscape is dynamic. When you’re at the helm of your SEO, you can test different strategies, see what resonates with your audience, and pivot accordingly. There’s no waiting on approvals or external consultations. You decide, and you implement.

Building In-house Expertise

Over time, with consistent effort, you or your team can develop significant SEO expertise. This knowledge stays within the company, fostering an environment of continuous learning and growth.

The Hidden Costs of DIY

While the monetary expenses might seem limited, one shouldn’t overlook the intangible costs associated with DIY SEO:

  • Time: As earlier mentioned, SEO is no walk in the park. It demands time and consistent effort. Every hour spent on SEO is an hour less on other crucial business functions.
  • Potential for Errors: Without deep expertise, it’s easy to make mistakes. Sometimes, these errors can lead to long-term damage, requiring even more time to rectify.
  • Slower Results: Professionals have the tools and knowledge to get quicker results. DIY often means a longer wait to see significant improvements in rankings.

The Professional Advantage: Beyond the Surface

While DIY SEO has its merits, professional SEO services like those offered by Searchical have distinct advantages that can be game-changers for businesses.

Customised Strategies

Professionals take the time to understand your business model, your competitors, and your target audience. They craft strategies tailored to fit your specific needs, ensuring better alignment with your goals.

Access to Advanced Tools

In the world of SEO, tools can make a significant difference. From tracking website performance, spying on competitors, to identifying optimal keywords, professional-grade tools (often pricey for individual subscriptions) are part and parcel of an SEO agency’s arsenal.

Multifaceted Skill Set

Good SEO isn’t just about understanding search engines. It’s about content creation, technical website optimisation, user experience design, and more. When you hire an expert or a team, you get access to a multifaceted skill set, ensuring all SEO aspects are holistically addressed.

Consistent Monitoring and Reporting

SEO requires continuous monitoring and tweaking. Professionals not only take care of these tasks but also provide regular reports showcasing performance, ensuring transparency and trust.

Adaptability to Changing SEO Landscape

The online world, especially the search environment, changes rapidly. SEO professionals keep their finger on the pulse, ensuring your strategies remain updated and compliant.

Making the Choice: Factors to Consider

It’s evident that both DIY and professional SEO have their strengths and limitations. Making a decision isn’t always straightforward. Here are a few things to ponder upon:

  1. Budget Constraints: If you’re tight on funds, starting with DIY SEO might seem appealing. However, consider the long-term ROI. Sometimes, investing in professional services can yield higher returns in the long run.
  2. Technical Acumen: If you or your team already have some understanding of SEO and the technical aspects of websites, starting with DIY could be viable. But remember, there’s more to SEO than meets the eye.
  3. Business Size and Scope: A local business targeting a small audience might manage with DIY efforts. However, larger businesses or those targeting a broad or highly competitive niche might benefit more from professional expertise.
  4. Growth Aspirations: If you envision your business scaling rapidly, professional SEO can set a strong foundation. It ensures that as your business grows, your digital presence does too.
  5. The Value of Time: Ask yourself, where is your time best spent? If delving into keyword research and backlink strategies isn’t the best use of your time, considering external help might be the way to go.

DIY SEO: Navigating the Intricacies

Going the DIY SEO route is akin to embarking on a journey through an intricate maze. The challenge is invigorating for some, but for others, the complexity might be intimidating. Let’s dissect this path further.

The DIY Learning Process

Online Courses & Workshops: The internet is filled with courses that guide novices through the basics of SEO. Websites like Coursera, Udemy, and even the Australian Digital Health Agency provide foundational knowledge.

Blogs & Articles: Renowned SEO experts share insights, latest trends, and tips through their blogs. Regularly following these can be enlightening. Our blog at Searchical’s can be great resources.

Forums & Communities: Platforms like Reddit or specialized SEO forums can be goldmines of information. Here, real people share their experiences, successes, and failures, giving a practical perspective.

Hands-on Experience

There’s no teacher like experience. Setting up a test website or blog can be a cost-effective way to practice SEO skills in real-time. Monitor your results, make changes, and see what works best. It’s all about trial and error.

Potential Setbacks of DIY SEO

While the learning opportunities are ample, the pitfalls are real too:

  • Overwhelm: The sheer volume of information available can be overwhelming. Distilling what’s relevant and up-to-date is a challenge.
  • Inconsistencies: SEO requires consistent effort. Business demands might distract from regular SEO tasks, affecting results.
  • Lack of Network: SEO also involves building relationships for backlinks and collaborations. Professionals usually have a network ready, but DIY-ers might need to start from scratch.

The SEO Expert Route: Beyond the Basics

Choosing an SEO expert, like those from Searchical, is like hiring a seasoned guide for your digital journey. We are navigated the maze before and know the quickest routes to success.

Structured Strategy Development

Expert agencies start with a comprehensive audit of your existing digital presence. Based on findings, they develop a structured, step-by-step plan tailored for your business, ensuring no stone is left unturned.

Diverse Expertise Under One Roof

An SEO agency is typically a melting pot of talent:

  • Content Strategists: Crafting content that resonates with your audience while being SEO-friendly.
  • Technical SEO Experts: Ensuring your website’s backend is optimised for search engines.
  • Link Builders: Building a network of high-quality backlinks to boost your site’s authority.
  • Analytics Gurus: Monitoring performance and tweaking strategies based on data.

Having access to this diverse skill set ensures a holistic approach to SEO.

Staying Ahead of the Curve

SEO isn’t static. With experts, you’re not just keeping up; you’re often ahead of the curve. They can predict trends and prepare your business in advance, ensuring you always have a competitive edge.

Efficiency & ROI

While hiring an expert is an investment, the efficiency they bring often results in a higher ROI. Their experience helps avoid common pitfalls, and their strategies are typically results-driven, ensuring every penny spent works towards tangible outcomes.

Peace of Mind

Perhaps one of the most underrated benefits is the peace of mind that comes with hiring an expert. Knowing that a critical aspect of your business’s online presence is in capable hands allows you to focus on what you do best – running your business.

The Hybrid Approach: Blending DIY with Expertise

For businesses that aren’t ready to fully relinquish control but acknowledge the need for expertise, there’s a middle path. A hybrid approach involves learning and managing certain aspects of SEO in-house while outsourcing specific, more complex tasks to experts.

In-house Content Creation with External Optimisation

Many businesses prefer creating content in-house, as it allows for a genuine brand voice. Once created, this content can be optimised by professionals for SEO.

Learning & Consultation

While the in-house team handles daily SEO tasks, regular consultations with experts ensure the strategy remains on track. This provides a learning opportunity for the in-house team while benefiting from expert guidance.

Task-specific Outsourcing

Certain SEO tasks, like link building or technical optimisation, might be too complex or time-consuming. In such cases, businesses can choose to outsource only these specific tasks while handling the rest in-house.

This approach offers a balance, allowing businesses to maintain control and build in-house expertise while still benefiting from professional insights and skills.


The debate between DIY SEO and hiring an SEO expert boils down to your priorities, skills, and budget. While DIY can be tempting, the expertise and resources that companies like Searchical offer can be the edge your business needs. If you’re looking to drive tangible results and elevate your online presence, it might be time to get in touch with us.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is SEO?
SEO stands for Search Engine Optimisation. It’s the practice of improving your site to increase its visibility on search engines.

Why is SEO important for my business?
It helps you attract organic (non-paid) traffic to your site, which can lead to increased brand awareness and sales.

How long does SEO take to show results?
It varies, but typically you might start seeing results in 4-6 months. However, SEO is a long-term investment.

Can I do SEO on my own?
Yes, but it requires time, effort, and continuous learning. For optimal results, consider professional help.

How often does Google update its algorithms?
Google makes minor changes almost daily, with major updates happening several times a year.

Is SEO only about keywords?
No, it covers aspects like site structure, user experience, mobile compatibility, and more.

What’s the difference between organic and paid search?
Organic search refers to unpaid search results, while paid search involves paying for top spots on search engines.

Why choose Searchical for my SEO needs?
With proven expertise and results, Searchical ensures tailored strategies to boost your online presence. Check out our testimonials for more.

Iman Bahrani
Founder & Director

  • Award-Winning SEO & Digital Marketing Specialist
  • Local Business Growth Expert
  • E-commerce Specialist
  • World’s 1st Crypto SEO

With well over a decade of experience as a Digital Marketing, SEO, and business consulting veteran, Iman Bahrani has kept his finger on a deep pulse of what it means to achieve maximum brand awareness and online impact, with experiences ranging from successful search engine optimization to effective social media campaigns. With clients that included ASX listed companies and some of the most recognized brand names as well as small-to-medium businesses across Australia, US, Canada, and UK, it was only a matter of time before Iman founded Searchical, Australia’s premier SEO company.

Share Button
By | 2023-10-27T07:45:44+00:00 October 27th, 2023|Categories: Blog|